discussion highlights

Discussion Highlights: Stereotypes

Last Week’s Discussion:

Last week the bookish community was in a bit of an uproar over a book containing some offensive stereotypes. As a result, I thought it necessary to discuss stereotypes in fiction and ways we might be able to remedy such an issue so as not to have it happen again. Let’s see what the discussioners had to say!

Breeanna said:

“As writers, it’s our duty to see the world complexly. As easy as it is to write a flat, pure evil character, it does an injustice to the world we live in and our readers, especially in YA and MG markets. […]Buy book by diverse authors, tweet at editors and publishers that you want more “own voices” stories, and lastly, like Melanie said, hold authors accountable who misrepresent the “other” with stereotypes and cop-outs.”

Carla said:

“I think by normalising it. […] this is the best way. To include it, but to keep it normal. To not always make it the focus (though I think that can be sometimes effective, too) but to make it as if it’s a part of normal life. If it’s projected as normal – which it should be, in all aspects – maybe it’ll get rid of the idea that some people/groups are more special than others.”

Lilyn said:

“I don’t know how we find the balance. One of the things that confuses me, as a reader, is correct representation of POC in books.[…]I’m never quite sure what I should be looking for in terms of ‘diversity’ and non-stereotyping. I mean, obviously I’m not looking for people to be portrayed as savages, idiots, etc. I’m talking more subtle than that.”

Rae said:

“It shouldn’t be difficult to represent POC correctly. Not stereotyping shouldn’t be difficult. If you can’t tell the difference between stereotypes and truth then that in itself is the first problem.”

Well, it seems some discussioners had a few suggestions for how we can fix this difficult problem we face in fiction. Are any of them right? Are any of these methods going to work? I don’t know. A lot of fiction is trial and error and I think it’s worth getting it wrong a few dozen times to ensure that we get it right. Stereotypes should no longer exist in fiction nor in reality. Let’s try and end it. What do you say?

Check out this week’s discussion on Thursday at 10am EST:
Writing: Point of View

3 thoughts on “Discussion Highlights: Stereotypes”

  1. The only thing that matters to me is a good story, everything else is secondary. If an author gets preachy, what I call “message fiction” I pass. Even if they’re speaking my language. If it’s an eBook I get samples now and just don’t buy it. I’ll browse pages at brick and mortar stores. And I check reader reviews. I read to escape, not to be lectured.

    And if I don’t like the world view of an author, I can just not buy it and let the market decide. But a truly good author, their politics and world view I’ll never know because they just told the dang story.

    Hope that wasn’t offensive… 🙈

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Nah. I think I see what you’re trying to say: a good author knows how to write a story that shows their perspectives without showing their perspectives. It’s just part of the story and well hidden instead of in your face and out there.


Leave a comment below! I'd love to hear from you!

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.